A small lie, a smaller cover-up, and the husband's closing argument: if you hadn't been paying attention, none of this would be a problem. That's not a defense. That's a confession with better branding.

The actual offense isn't the lie. It's the retrofit: he did wrong, got caught, and reached for the one explanation that puts you on trial. "You overanalyze everything" isn't a description of your behavior. It's a reframe that makes your perception the issue. The lie becomes a natural consequence of your attention span. That's the move where lying stops being the problem and becomes the thing you provoked by noticing it.
The therapy detail isn't a side note. In eighteen months, you've cried a handful of times, and when you did, he mocked you for it a week later and called it playing the victim. That moment isn't a footnote; it's the mechanism. Now you hesitate to speak in session, which means the room designed for honesty is being slowly converted into a room you can't use. He doesn't need to stop you from talking. He just needs you to believe talking will cost you.
The comments are split, which is how these threads always go. One measure says don't let a partner rewrite your memory of what happened; another invites you to audit your own overanalysis. The split is the tell: the story rewards anyone willing to treat your perception as the crime scene. But there's no version where noticing a lie is the harm. The harm is the lie.
If what you call overanalyzing is just noticing patterns, keep the habit. The only question is who it's costing.